Conclusion

For almost two decades now, the residents of the Douglas Shire have been participating in a social and environmental experiment. These attempts to pioneer a socially, economically and environmentally sustainable community are heart-felt and passionate.
The loss of the Douglas Shire’s unique character cannot be outweighed by any purported advantages of amalgamation. Amalgamation is a win-lose scenario, with the Douglas Shire on the losing side.
Although there may be some local governments which do struggle financially, are unable to meet the essential needs of their communities, and should therefore be considered for amalgamation, plainly the Douglas Shire cannot be considered among them.

A recent independent survey found that more than 70% of the Douglas Shire residents are opposed to amalgamation. On democratic principles alone, there is no justification for amalgamating the Douglas Shire.